Reproducibility contract¶
A benchmark result is only reviewable when its configuration and route through the system can be reconstructed. For gMAS evaluations, preserve the following with every run.
Required run artifact¶
- serialized graph before and after execution;
- prompt and role definitions;
- model and endpoint identifiers, without credentials;
- decoding parameters and concurrency limits;
- random seeds where applicable;
- provider token-usage fields;
- normalized predictions and reference answers;
- JSONL or equivalent execution traces;
- dataset name, version, split, and sample identifiers;
- topology template and metric reducer;
- baseline and gMAS runner configuration.
Tool-enabled benchmarks must also record tool availability, search/browser settings, exact tool budgets, answer-normalization logic, and infrastructure-error classification.
Common setup¶
On POSIX shells, use cp benchmarks/.env.example benchmarks/.env. Fill in an OpenAI-compatible endpoint through LLM_API_KEY, LLM_BASE_URL, and LLM_MODEL. The ablation track also accepts BENCH_* overrides for strong/weak models and experiment controls.
Generated outputs belong under benchmark_logs/ or benchmarks_logs/; both paths are excluded from Git to avoid committing credentials, large provider payloads, or transient browser artifacts.
Entry points¶
| Track | Command |
|---|---|
| Matched topology | uv run python -m benchmarks.topology.run --help |
| Runtime ablations | uv run python -m benchmarks.ablations.run --help |
| GAIA | uv run python -m benchmarks.gaia.run --help |
| AgentPrune | uv run python -m benchmarks.agentprune.run |
| Terminal-Bench | See benchmarks/terminal_bench/README.md |
Reporting checklist¶
- Run a smoke test before the complete benchmark.
- Keep both compared systems on the same task set and operational budget.
- Include failures in the accuracy denominator unless a documented infrastructure rule excludes them.
- Report latency, tokens, and quality separately; do not collapse them into “faster” or “better.”
- Label non-significant accuracy changes as observed effects.
- Keep exploratory harnesses out of paper result tables until they have a matched protocol and a complete run.